The Beatles and Motown are often seen and heard as very separate musical styles. Listen to the Beatles’ Taxman as a stereo mix. Then listen to the left side only and lastly the right side only. You can do this by listening to only one headphoone or by using your music playback app’s preferences to listen to only one side (for instance, a slider in iTunes app preferences). The original Taxman has two different sounding tracks, left and right. This was also recorded on a 4-track tape machine in 1966 at Abbey Road. Note the differences between the stereo mix and the two monaural mixes. Take notes and times of differences perceived.
Listen to Marvin Gaye’s What’s Goin’ On?, first in its conventional form as a studio mix originally recorded at Motown Studios in 1970. Then listen to the track titled What’s Goin On? Incremental mix, attached at the bottom of this text. An incremental mix is a track-by-track tape, usually spun onto cassette for homework listening by the artists. In this case, that would be Paul Riser, arranger at Motown and a good friend. As this track progresses, you will learn two things:
You will get a very personal lesson–and in my opinion, a profoundly beautiful one–from Marvin about the emotional power of perfect solo singing; and,
You will hear his voice combined with other track(s) as the song continues–a lesson in call-and-response on several levels.
Then consult the attached document on Abbey Road recording technologies and Motown technologies. You will be surprised by how different they are.
In this forum, respond to the following questions: how did the two recording technologies change the approach of the 1966 4-track Beatles compared to that, just 5 years later, of the 8-track Marvin Gaye? What are the technological and musical differences you hear? Remember that within another 5 years, tape recording would change again into 24-tracks, not 8-tracks.
Finished the post and write a short response to two student:
1. Shreejana Pokhrel
I find it very different music composition on both recording, comparing 4-track Beatles “Taxman” and 8 Track by Marvin Gaye’s. By listening to both music multiple times, I find that music quality on both recording is little different and listening to Beatles, the sound of music seems different if I listen it very carefully and also, I felt that music and vocal is spreading on right and left equally. Also, by listening to Taxman recorded, I can tell it is older version of recording and the sound effect on the guitar and instrument used is totally different and older version.
Where as listening to Marvin Gayes Whats going on, I felt that song is composed very beautifully and the music and sound effect on song are equally distributed with clarity on lyrics and rhythm. Comparing these two beautiful songs is very difficult task since both of these compositions were hit during their own time with lots of changes on technologies, instrument and rhythm but if I have chose the between these two recording, I would prefer listening to Whats going on, since the composition is very clear along with the vocal and instrument used to composed this music.
2.Briana Johnson
While listening to the Beatles’ Taxman stereo mix, with just the right headphone, the song started with someone coughing loudly. Also, I could hear that the vocals were leading the song. At 0:39 you hear a brief introduction of an electric guitar, and then at 1:20, there is an electric guitar solo. The combination of vocals + guitar is re-introduced around 1:50. When listening with the left headphone only, the instruments are clearly leading the song, and vocals seem to take the background. The overall sound felt separate, even when listening with both headphones in. In Marvin Gaye’s What’s going on, you can tell that technological advances had happened by this point because the song sounds more robust and polished.
Overall I feel that Marvin’s song is a lot more clear-sounded and the vocal arrangement is close to perfect, whereas the Beatles’ Taxman sounds imperfect and not polished. What’s going on sounds more put together because you can hear the instruments and vocals in both headphones and in my opinion I prefer this song over Taxman.
Use the order calculator below and get started! Contact our live support team for any assistance or inquiry.
[order_calculator]
