This is the instructions from the first essay I need revision for I will upload the document for the revision instructions and my original essay.
Focus
English 1102 Fall 2020
E1: Marcus Initiation Essay: Synthesis and Application of Literary Criticism (100pts.)
Prof. Ravita
Goal: To practice analysis and analytical essay writing by presenting and applying a concept to short stories.
Preliminary Draft Post due: Wed., Feb. 24
Peer Review Discussion Replies due: Fri., Feb. 26, 11:30p [No copy editing, please. We will keep the review simple and focused on content.]
Smarthinking Report due: Wed., Mar. 3, 11:30p
Final Version due: Fri., Mar. 5, 11:30p
*Adjustments to the schedule may be made to meet the needs of the class.
Assignment:
Present the concept of initiation as defined by Mordecai Marcus and use two or three stories from our reading list to demonstrate the application of Marcus definition. Explain how each meets Mordecai Marcus proposed definition of an initiation story, and what type of initiation the protagonist experiences. Do not try to write an in-depth analysis of each story.
Stories:
First Confession Frank OConnor The Lesson Toni Cade Bambara (not covered in class)
A Visit of Charity Eudora Welty The Man Who Was Almost a Man Richard Wright
Gorilla, My Love Toni Cade Bambara Barn Burning William Faulkner (not covered in class)
Audience: Address a wide audience of Perimeter students taking English class. Everyone has read coming of age stories at some point, but they have not necessarily read the particular ones listed above, and they have not been given a specific, detailed definition an initiation story.
Elements to Include and Consider:
Introduction: Make sure to present Mordecai Marcuss definition, both the general definition and the definitions of tentative, uncompleted, and decisive initiations. Try to paraphrase (retell accurately in your own words) as much as possible but use quoted phrases as needed.
Thesis: What would the thesis statement for the essay be? Since the focus is on the application of the initiation concept, you may wish to offer some judgment as to the usefulness of Marcuss definition. Or, if you happen to choose stories that demonstrate one type of initiation, your thesis might claim that the two or three stories you have chosen serve as good (or the best) examples of that type.
Body:
Make sure to use two or three stories. You are doing what Marcus does in his article giving examples of applying the definition to help others understand it and test how well it works. You are just using fewer stories for illustration than Marcus uses.
Organization: Handling one story at a time (block method) will be easier to organize.
Some plot overview and presentation of the characters basic situation is needed to introduce readers to each story, but you are not trying to write an in-depth analysis of each story; there is not enough space for that. The emphasis is on the application of the definition.
Be sure to provide more complete and specific explanation to support the choice of initiation type than provided in a discussion post. This means referring to specific parts of the definition for tentative, uncompleted, or decisive initiations and trying to articulate what the character understands (or not) and to what extent. To support your claim about type of initiation for the protagonist, its important to explain the characters degree of innocence or maturity prior to any pivotal moment(s) in the story. If a story seems to qualify as an initiation story but is difficult to classify as one type or another, present the case for each classification.
Conclusion: You might evaluate the usefulness of Marcuss definition in distinguishing a particular group of stories about character development. Would you further narrow the definition that Marcus presents to one type/stage of initiation, keep as it is, or expand it in some way?
Works Cited page: Include an entry for each story and the Marcus article. For Wright and Faulkner, we do not have complete information, so just provide what is available.
Evaluation: The essay will be evaluated according to the accuracy of the definition, the depth and specificity of the discussion, the organization and articulation of ideas, overall presentation and formatting. The PC Freshman Composition Rubric is located within the syllabus in the Getting Started module. Good luck!
MLA format: all margins 1; double-spaced throughout; name, date, assignment on upper left, page number on upper right;
Work Cited entry double-spaced on its own page. A sample or a link to one will be provided.
Length: 2 3 pages; 600-word minimum.
Sources Permitted:
texts of the stories (the primary sources)
What Is an Initiation Story? Mordecai Marcus; this is the only source of opinion/criticism/analysis/interpretation that may be used. In this assignment, it is being used as a primary source even though it is a critical article.
Sources of fact (history or biography) are permitted. Examples: such as prices of guns, information about a historical period, information about a setting, Catholicism, etc.
Use the order calculator below and get started! Contact our live support team for any assistance or inquiry.
[order_calculator]