Quarter Four Focus: Philosophy
Read ONE of the following:
Plato Meno
Rene Descartes Meditations on First Philosophy
Henry David Thoreau Walden
Joseph Campbell The Hero with a Thousand Faces
Bertrand Russell The Problems of Philosophy
Sarah Bakewell At the Existentialist Cafe
Rhetorical Reflection due 4/16 via Turnitin:
In The Company We Keep: An Ethics of Fiction, Wayne Booth characterizes every readers relationship with a book as a friendship. In a review of this book, Thomas Conley summarizes Booths perspective in this way:
Booth suggests that we see the act of reading as one of people meeting and forming bonds. Considered under the friendship metaphor, all stories can be regarded not as puzzles or games but as companions, friends; and the implied authors of all stories can accordingly be viewed as offering me some sort of gift as a friendship offering, as it were. We view as friends those who offer us either something that will give us pleasure or something that will be useful to us, or a kind of company that is not only pleasurable and profitable, but good for its own sake. Just as we "rate" friends according to what they offer, with the fullest friendship being that which is "good for its own sake," so we can rate implied authors and the narratives they offer us. (163)
From this perspective, the critical questions are What kind of friend is this book to me? and Why do I think so? We all have good friends, difficult friends, and friends that we might describe as wise, sympathetic, crazy, confused, disappointing, devious, troubled, or dependent. We even have false friends who trick us or take advantage of us.
Booth outlines seven ways that books, our reading friends, can vary (179-80). These categories can be turned into several types of questions that could be used to help us think about our relationship to the book and the implied author and thus evaluate the nature and the quality of our friendship with the book.
Quantity
Responsibility
Intimacy
Intensity
Coherence
Distance
Range
Prompt: Write a multi-paragraph essay in which you analyze the rhetorical choices made by the author to achieve a specific rhetorical purpose with the audience. For the purposes of the Q3 and Q4 Rhetorical Reading Reflection Essays, have the rhetorical purpose be one of the seven ways an author establishes a relationship with his/her audience. Be sure to use textual evidence from your selected reading to enhance your argument.
(Note the appropriate quarter in parentheses)
Quantity: By quantity Booth means how long the work is and how densely it is packed with experiences for the reader.
Questions for reflection: (Q4 Philosophy Reflection)
Is the book (or story) too long, too short, or just right? Why do you say so?
Is the book (or story) densely packed with important ideas and experiences, or is it wordy and full of unnecessary sentences? What are some examples?
Responsibility: Booth says that books differ in the degree of responsibility they grant to uswhat we might call the level of reciprocity or domination between author and reader. Here Booth talks about whether or not the implied author treats us as equals or tries to appear superior to us.
Questions for reflection: (Q3 Trade Book Reflection)
Does the author treat you as an equal?
Does the author talk down to you or act like he or she is superior? Why do you feel this way?
Are there some specific examples in the text that show why?
Intimacy: By intimacy Booth means the degree to which the author allows us access to his or her thoughts and feelings.
Questions for reflection: (Q3 Trade Book Reflection)
Does the author feel like a close friend?
Does the author reveal intimate thoughts and feelings?
Do you like this author? Why or why not?
Are there examples in the text that support your feelings about the relationship?
Intensity: By intensity Booth means the degree of concentration or engagement the book requires, or perhaps inspires, from total concentration to slack comfortable, slowly-ripening acquaintance (180).
Questions for reflection: (Q4 Philosophy Reflection)
Does this book (or story) require intense concentration to read, or is it a good book to read at the beach?
Do you feel powerfully engaged with the book (or story)? Do you strongly want to read it?
Does it take time to get interested in it?
Is it only mildly interesting? Are you bored by it?
What about the book makes you feel the way you do?
Coherence: By coherence Booth means whether the world of the work is consistent or contradictory.
Questions for reflection: (Q4 Philosophy Reflection)
Does the world of the book (or story) make sense?
If there are confusing or contradictory elements, is it because the narrator or viewpoint character has a limited understanding or viewpoint?
Are the contradictions part of the reason the book (or story) is interesting?
What are some examples?
Distance: Booth discusses the distance between the world of the book and our own, that is, in the familiarity or strangeness of the world we enterthe amount of challenge, or otherness, that it presents to the reader. Booth notes that an author demanding a great quantity of unfamiliar work from a reader is a very different kind of friend from an author who gives us a lot of what we already have and love (194). Science fiction novels that take place in alien worlds populated by alien characters often present this sort of problem. However, such an alien world can be strange, distant, but still coherent.
Questions for reflection: (Q4 Philosophy Reflection)
Do you find the world of the book (or story) strange and hard to understand?
Does the book (or story) help you understand a world and characters that are very different from what you are used to? Or is the world familiar and comfortable?
What are some details from the book (or story) that support your feelings about the world of the book?
Range: Booth argues that books differ in the range of activities suggested, invited, or demanded. He notes that some authors offer beauty, some truth, and some goodness, but others offer the whole range of experiences, covering every topic included in our real world. Some books are very focused on a single issue or kind of experience.
Questions for reflection: (Q3 Trade Book Reflection)
What kinds of experiences does this book (or story) offer?
Does it portray a wide-ranging world with lots of different issues and characters, or is it narrowly focused on a few individuals?
Is it enjoyable because the language and the images are beautiful?
Does it teach some kind of universal truth?
Does it help you become a better person?
What is it about this book that makes it worth reading? Or if it is not worth reading, what are its flaws and problems?
Use the order calculator below and get started! Contact our live support team for any assistance or inquiry.
[order_calculator]