Goal
Write a 3-4 page (double-spaced by MLA guidelines) rhetorical analysis over “Activist Athletes.” You may find this article beginning on p. 765 of your Everything’s an Argument.
A rhetorical analysis assesses the strengths, weaknesses, and methods used in the writing to inform the readers how well or how poorly the original writer communicated his/her thesis based upon the principles of quality argument and the three appeals. (This is NOT I liked it; I didnt like it” nor is this a summary of what the author said. Your work is NOT agreeing or disagreeing with the source.)
A rhetorical analysis requires you to apply critical reading/thinking skills to focus on the aspects of the text, to break off the parts of the whole to investigate how the parts fit together. The goal of rhetorical analysis is to articulate HOW the author writes, (the effectiveness) not simply WHAT she/he writes and to examine the success (or failure) of the piece based upon the rhetorical elements.
Process:
Print a copy of your source “Activist Athletes” or annotate it within your text. (Hint: some students have chosen to highlight sections in different colors: for example, any special connotations of language in blue; appeals to logic in yellow. This method helps them organize their body paragraphs.)
Read Chapter 6 of your Everything’s an Argument.
Read your source several times, paying special attention to not only what the author is saying but also how she presents the ideas.
Analyze the context and the text by reviewing the questions on p. 100 of your Everything’s an Argument.
Write your draft.
a. Devise a thesis statement or claim. It is mandatory that YOU develop your own thesis about the essays effectiveness. (Dont simply restate the original authors thesis.) Create a thesis in which you analyze how (un)successful the author was in developing his message and why youve come to this conclusion. Review pp. 125-6 of Everything’s an Argument. This link Formulating a Thesis downloadoffers some additional assistance in creating your thesis.
How can I describe what this argument achieves?
Which of the rhetorical framework elements influence the readers the most?
How do those elements interact?
Remember, you don’t have to agree/disagree with the argument that the author is making; pay attention to how well the argument works–even if you dislike it! Evaluate the writing the author does–not what he/she “shoulda, woulda, coulda” done.
b. Support your thesis with topic sentences that reflect the ideas of the thesis. Your essay should focus on supporting the assertion in your thesis with each paragraph devoted to explaining and supporting a particular part of your argument. Expand the most important separate essentials that contribute (or hinder) the authors goal. Provide examples from the original essay! Many students don’t offer adequate and varied evidence. ONE example is not enough to prove your ideas. Choose evidence from throughout the original source (not just the first page, for example).
c. Make sure you are analyzing, not just summarizing the original article. Develop paragraphs that address individual elements (complete with topic sentences that relate to your thesis!) Remember that saying the author is successful is not the same as proving it!
d. Support your essay with quotations and paraphrases, using MLA style. Don’t copy without quotation marks. You may choose to put the evidence from the source into your own words. Utilize the techniques of integrating quotations effectively, avoiding dropped quotations.
e. Organize your work. You should work chronologically through the essay from beginning to middle to end. Your paragraphs may discuss ONE element, but provide evidence chronologically.
f. Write a logical introduction to interest your audience.
g. Conclude your essay. Can you make an insightful observation as a result of your analysis?
h. Format your essay according to the MLA guidelines.
i. Use in-text citations (just the page number (pp.765-770 for the exact evidence.) You do not need to repeat the name “Sarah Brown” each time because you have only one source, Brown’s!
Example:
Brown’s work is effective because she offers credible sources: She refers to Harry Edwards as a “prominent sports sociologist” (767) and Ray Anderson, Arizona State’s Athletic Director (769).
Points to Ponder:
Evaluate the essay, not the topic. If the original essay is about nutrition, then your essay is NOT about nutrition. Its about how well the author articulated and supported his/her assertion about nutrition. This essay does not ask for your opinion about nutrition; it’s your opinion about how well the author developed HIS/HER work about the topic.
This is not a summary. Assume that the readers of YOUR essay have read the original. Use some short (1-2 sentences) summary sentences to support your analysis, but avoid summarizing all the ideas the original author offered.
Avoid “defining” for the audience. The audience will understand what “pathos” is by your examples offered. Do ensure that you refer to a specific emotion, not just “pathos” generally.
Avoid both I and “you” as the point of view of your essay; dont apologize for your thinking about the strengths and weaknesses of the essay. For example, dont say I think the authors sarcastic tone alienates his readers simply eliminate the first two words! Avoid using “you” in the essay.
There are two voices in your essayyours and the original authors. Ensure that your audience knows at all times whose opinion is whose.
Revision
Everything’s an Argument, pp. 129-30 offers you some specific questions to help you “re-think” your ideas.
Ensure that every paragraph is about one topic and has a topic sentence that reflects your thinking, not a “fact.” Ensure that every paragraph has adequate and thorough evidence to support your ideas.
Effective word choice in college level writing:
focuses on specific, active verbs.
utilizes strong, clear and specific nouns. Avoid the use of these words: thing, everything, something, nothing, anything.
doesn’t need flowery or vague adjectives and adverbs: nice, interesting, great, very, really, extremely.
Rubric
Rhetorical Analysis
Rhetorical Analysis
Criteria Ratings Pts
This criterion is linked to a Learning OutcomeThesis and Evidence
20 to >17.0 pts
Advanced
Clearly articulates the thesis; assertive thesis has a thoughtful evaluation of HOW the author uses language including the rhetorical choices. Offers a summary of the key ideas to be developed. Significant relevant evidence supports the claim.
17 to >14.0 pts
Proficient
Assertive thesis makes an interesting claim about how the author uses language. Relevant evidence supports the claim.
14 to >11.0 pts
Acceptable
Thesis makes a general assertion about how the author uses language; some mis-interpretation of the text. Cursory evidence is provided to support the assertion.
11 to >0.0 pts
Weak
Descriptive thesis simply summarizes the text. Evidence is lacking to support the claim.
0 pts
Failing
Missing thesis.
20 pts
This criterion is linked to a Learning OutcomeAnalysis
20 to >17.0 pts
Advanced
Source text ideas about the rhetorical choices is thorough and effective; focus on analytical thinking.
17 to >14.0 pts
Proficient
Source text about rhetorical choices is well-done with a focus on mostly analytical thinking.
14 to >11.0 pts
Acceptable
Source text ideas about rhetorical choices is incomplete or too brief; an overuse of summary rather than analysis
11 to >0.0 pts
Weak
Overuse of own ideas about the issue rather than an analysis of source text.
0 pts
Failing
No analytic thinking; response or summary. Student responds to the topic rather than an analysis of the writing.
20 pts
This criterion is linked to a Learning OutcomeParagraphs
20 to >17.0 pts
Advanced
Paragraphs are skillful, each making a significant assertive observation about the rhetorical choices, with significant and appropriate evidence from the text. Quotations to support the key ideas are introduced and integrated seamlessly.
17 to >14.0 pts
Proficient
Paragraphs have topic sentences to make observations about language; documents assertions with multiple examples of support. Quotations are usually introduced and integrated.
14 to >11.0 pts
Accepable
Paragraphs have inconsistent topic sentences or documents with cursory evidence from the text. Some dropped quotations or several quotations not introduced and integrated.
11 to >0.0 pts
Weak
Paragraph topic sentences do little more than summarize the text; little evidence from the text. Many dropped quotations or quotations that are not introduced or integrated.
0 pts
Failing
Topic sentences reflect only “fact”; no supporting evidence is offered. Paragraphs do not offer integrated quotations.
20 pts
This criterion is linked to a Learning OutcomeIntroduction & Conclusion
10 pts
Advanced
Introduction engages the reader and provides the context; Conclusion connects rhetorical points.
8.5 pts
Proficient
Introduction provides specific context; conclusion ties together the points made.
7 pts
Acceptab le
Introduction provides general context; conclusion ties together most of the ideas but may simply repeat the language.
5.5 pts
Weak
Introduction does not engage the reader; Conclusion is absent or simple summary.
0 pts
Failing
No submission
10 pts
This criterion is linked to a Learning OutcomeWord Choice
20 pts
Advanced
Academic vocabulary, accurate in context; tone and word choice appropriate for academic audience
17 pts
Proficient
Uses mostly college-level vocabulary; tone and word choice are mostly appropriate for the audience.
14 pts
Acceptable
Some mis-use of language; tone and word choice may appeal to limited audience. Some word choices are inappropriate.
11 pts
Weak
Poor language choices do not sustain audience interest.
0 pts
Failing
No submission
20 pts
This criterion is linked to a Learning OutcomeMUG (Mechanics, Usage, and Grammar) & MLA
10 pts
Advanced
Flawless presentation.
8.5 pts
Proficient
Some errors, but they do not detract from the meaning.
7 pts
Acceptable
Significant errors detract from the meaning.
5.5 pts
Weak
Glaring errors in MUG and MLA style which render the work difficult to read. No submission.
0 pts
Failing
No submission
10 pts
Total
Use the order calculator below and get started! Contact our live support team for any assistance or inquiry.
[order_calculator]