Choose one (1) case from the chapters assigned for the week (see below) and provide a summary (approx 150 words) supporting either the plaintiff or the defendant based on the facts of the case and your interpretation of the law. You need to do some research on the case selected and provide links to that research which assisted you in your decision. Check at least 2 other sources as part of your independent research. Respond to another student’s posting for full credit.
Fourth Amendment Protection from Unreasonable Search and Seizure
CASE 7.8Explain the Fourth Amendment protection from unreasonable search and seizure.
In many criminal cases, the government relies on information obtained from searches of individuals and businesses. The Fourth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution protects persons and corporations from overzealous investigative activities by the government. It protects the rights of the people from unreasonable search and seizure by the government. It permits people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects. Information Technology Electronic Communications Privacy Act The Electronic Communications Privacy Act (ECPA)11 makes it a crime to intercept an electronic communication at the point of transmission, while in transit, when stored by a router or server, or after receipt by the intended recipient. An electronic communication includes any transfer of signals, writings, images, sounds, data, or intelligence of any nature. The ECPA makes it illegal to access email while in transmission or stored. Example Henry owns a computer on which he sends and receives email. Harriet learns Henrys access code to his email account. Harriet opens Henrys email and reads his emails. Harriet has violated the ECPA. Exceptions The ECPA provides that stored electronic communications may be accessed without violating the law by the following: The party or entity providing the electronic communication service. The primary example would be an employer who can access stored email communications of employees using the employers service. Government and law enforcement entities that are investigating suspected illegal activity. Disclosure would be required only pursuant to a valid warrant. Example John works for the National Paper Corporation. In his job, he has access to a computer on which to conduct work for his employer. John receives and sends email that is work-related. John also has access on his computer to the internet. The National Paper Corporation investigates what John has been viewing and what he has stored on his computer. During its investigation, the National Paper Corporation discovers that John has been viewing and storing child pornography images. The National Paper Corporation fires John for his conduct because it violates company policy of which John is aware. Here, the National Paper Company did not violate ECPA. The ECPA provides for criminal penalties. In addition, the ECPA provides that an injured party may sue for civil damages for violations of the ECPA. Reasonable search and seizure by the government is lawful. Search warrants based on probable cause are necessary in most cases. Such a warrant specifically states the place and scope of the authorized search. General searches beyond the specified area are forbidden. Warrantless searches are permitted only (1) incident to arrest, (2) where evidence is in plain view, or (3) in exigent circumstances such as when it is likely that evidence will be destroyed. Warrantless searches are judged by the probable cause standard. Example The police obtained a search warrant to attach a global positioning system (GPS) to a suspects automobile, and the warrant stated that the device be installed within 10 days. The police, however, did not install the device until the 11th day. The U.S. Supreme Court held that this was an unconstitutional search and that the evidence obtained from the search be excluded from evidence.12 Exclusionary Rule Evidence obtained from an unreasonable search and seizure is considered tainted evidence (fruit of a tainted tree). Under the exclusionary rule, such evidence can generally be prohibited from introduction at a trial or an administrative proceeding against the person searched. However, this evidence is freely admissible against other persons. The U.S. Supreme Court created a good faith exception to the exclusionary rule.13 This exception allows evidence obtained illegally to be introduced as evidence against the accused if the police officers who conducted the unreasonable search reasonably believed that they were acting pursuant to a lawful search warrant. U.S. Supreme Court, Washington DC In the United States, suspected criminals are given many rights by the U.S. Constitution and state constitutions. Parties in the United States are free from unreasonable searches and seizures of evidence, and any evidence obtained illegally is considered tainted evidence and cannot be used in court. People who are suspected of a criminal act may assert their right of privilege against self-incrimination and may choose not to testify at any pretrial proceedings or at trial. In addition, if convicted of a crime, the criminal is free from cruel and unusual punishment. Critical Legal Thinking Does the exclusionary rule allow some guilty parties to go free? Is this an acceptable result when balanced against the protections afforded by the Fourth Amendment? The following U.S. Supreme Court case involves the issue of searching cellphones. Case 7.3 U.S. supreme court case Search of Cellphones Riley v. California 134 S.Ct. 2473, 2014 U.S. Lexis 4497 (2014) Supreme Court of the United States Our answer to the question of what police must do before searching a cellphone seized incident to an arrest is accordingly simpleget a warrant. Roberts, Chief Justice Facts David Riley was stopped for driving with expired registration tags. A search of the car turned up two concealed and loaded firearms. The police confiscated Rileys smartphone and went through it and found gang related information and a photograph of Riley in front of a car they suspected to be involved in a shooting a few weeks earlier. Based on the information retrieved from the cellphone Riley was charged with that earlier shooting, with firing at an occupied vehicle, assault with a semiautomatic weapon, and attempted murder. Riley was convicted of all charges and was sentenced to 15 years in prison. Prior to trial, Riley moved to suppress the evidence the police obtained from his cellphone, alleging that the information obtained from his phone was the fruit of an unconstitutional search in violation of the Fourth Amendment. The court denied Rileys request. After appeal, the U.S. Supreme Court granted certiorari to hear the case. Issue Can the police, without a warrant, search digital information on a cellphone from an individual who has been arrested? Language of the U.S. Supreme Court Courts have approved searches of a variety of personal items carried by an arrestee (e.g., billfolds, address books, wallets, and purses). Cellphones differ in both a quantitative and qualitative sense from other objects that might be kept on an arrestees person. Modern cellphones are not just another technological convenience. With all they contain and all they may reveal, they hold for many Americans the privacies of life. Our answer to the question of what police must do before searching a cellphone seized incident to an arrest is accordingly simpleget a warrant.
RESPONSE TO Janani: in 6 sentence or a paragraph
For this week’s discussion, I have selected the case of Search of Cellphones Riley v. California. David Riley, was arrested for a traffic violation which resulted in the discovery of loaded firearms in his car. The officers subsequently seized Riley’s phone, and searched through the messages, contacts, videos, and photographs. Based in part on the data stored on Riley’s phone, the officers charged Riley with an unrelated shooting that had taken place several weeks prior to his arrest. Before trial, Riley moved to suppress the evidence regarding his gang affiliation that had been acquired through his cell phone. His motion was denied. The jury convicted Riley to 15 years of imprisonment. However, the courts ruled that the police cannot search the cell phone data without a warrant which was foregone measure in this case. The court’s decision was based on the following:
the search of cell phone digital data is not needed to promote legitimate governmental interests in police safety and preservation of evidence during an arrest,
the search of cell phone digital data represents a major intrusion on the arrestees privacy
Although, the courts ruled the search of the cell phone to be illegal and an intrusion on privacy, with the current evidence this was considered a foregone measure and Riley’s conviction was upheld.
Cyber laws are ever evolving and I agree with the courts decision on this case. Although the court decided that the search was unlawful, due to nature of the crime and the overwhelming evidence produced, the court upheld the verdict on Riley.
Response in 6 sentences or a Paragraph______________
2, response to Emma post:
Emma Ealem
MondayApr 5 at 11:19am
Manage Discussion Entry
Kawaauhau v. Geiger, 523 U.S. 57, 118 S. Ct. 974, 1998 U.S. Lexis 1595 (Supreme Court of the United States)
The plaintiff in the case is Margaret Kawaauhau. The defendant in the case is Dr. Paul Geiger. Margaret Kawaauhau sought treatment from Dr. Paul Geiger for a foot injury, (Cheeseman, 1998, p. 299). Dr. Geiger admitted her in the hospital and he began a treatment regimen that included penicillin. He wanted to save her some money, so he prescribed oral penicillin. During the course of her hospital stay, he left to go on a business trip. The attending physicians decided she should be transferred to an infectious disease specialist. Dr. Geiger returned from his trip and he canceled the orders to transfer her because he felt the penicillin was enough to cure her. Within days her condition worsens and her leg was amputated.
To add salt to her injury, Dr. Geiger didnt have malpractice insurance and he wanted to have his lawsuit discharged in bankruptcy court. According to Cornell Law, the Bankruptcy Court concluded that Geigers treatment fell far below the appropriate standard of care and therefore ranked as willful and malicious. Section 523(a) (6)s exemption from discharge, the en banc court held, is confined to debts based on what the law has for generations called an intentional tort. Id., at 852. On this view, a debt for malpractice, because it is based on conduct that is negligent or reckless, rather than intentional, remains dischargeable.
Ms. Kawaauhau was awarded $355,000 in damages. I agree with the judgement. I feel she should have been awarded more. Personally, I would have sued the hospital for allowing him to be on site without insurance.
Cite:
“Kawaauhau v. Geiger.” Oyez, www.oyez.org/cases/1997/97-115. Accessed 5 Apr. 2021.
Chesseman, H. (2018). Legal Environment of Business. Ninth Edition
Kawaauhau v. Geiger, 523 U.S. 57 (1998). (n.d.). Cornell Law. Retrieved April 5, 2021, from https://www.law.cornell.edu/supct/html/97-115.ZO.htm
Response in 6 sentences or a Paragraph
Use the order calculator below and get started! Contact our live support team for any assistance or inquiry.
[order_calculator]
