Does the Identity Argument provide us with additional tools to evaluate this controversy beyond what conventional ethics offers?

Last summer a Google engineer was fired for a controversial memo he sent to various internal Google project groups suggesting that the low number of female coders had less to do with bias against women and more with the nature of the female brain. Essentially, he claimed, women aren’t as interested in coding as men are.

This eventually led to a public backlash against Google with demands to sack the engineer. In August, the engineer was terminated and now is suing Google on the basis of systematic discrimination against white males.

From the short description above, you can see how complex this drama has become.

Does the Identity Argument provide us with additional tools to evaluate this controversy beyond what conventional ethics offers?

If you think it does, use the identity argument as an ethical tool to summarize what you think are the main moral features in the controversy.

If you are not convinced we can effectively use the identity argument to sort through moral dilemmas, use the Google controversy to highlight weaknesses in the identity argument.

Follow the link below to read the latest developments on the Google drama:
Google drama

PS: It would be good if you focused on some real-world dilemmas faced by individual people. You should try to explain more clearly what issue you want to discuss. You should aim to explain this using simpler language and more succinctly.

Use the order calculator below and get started! Contact our live support team for any assistance or inquiry.

[order_calculator]