How could physicians have reconciled gag rules contained in some for-profit HMO contracts with their responsibility to always act in the best interests of their individual patients?

***Case 2: HMO Contracts

***I need this book used with references:
Ethics in Health Administration: A Practical Approach for Decision Makers, 3rd edition by Eileen E. Morrison (Jones & Bartlett Learning, 2016) ISBN 978-1-284-07065-1

***In the mid-1990s, many patients belonging to for-profit Health Maintenance Organizations (HMOs) began to question the candor of the recommendations they received from their doctors. A clause in many HMO contracts at that time, referred to by critics as a gag rule, forbade physicians from disclosing certain information to their patients, including financial incentives provided by the HMOs to encourage physicians to limit care and reduce costs. Critics charged that many HMOs were offering doctors financial incentives to minimize care and to recommend fewer or less costly treatments to their patients. Nevertheless, managed care, HMOs, and other cost-savings measures help to bring under control runaway medical costs associated with the fee-for-service system.

In 1996, the US federal government joined several states in outlawing such gag rules.

***Questions for Discussion
1. How could physicians have reconciled gag rules contained in some for-profit HMO contracts with their responsibility to always act in the best interests of their individual patients? To what extend did such clauses present conflicting interests?
2. What are the responsibilities of physicians to fully inform their patients about treatment options?

Use the order calculator below and get started! Contact our live support team for any assistance or inquiry.

[order_calculator]