Image/Object Analysis

3-5 Page Analysis of an Image or Object

Over the course of this semester, we will use art as evidence of the historical changes in childhood experience and childhoods conception across time and place. On 10/19 we will specifically discuss material culture, and on 10/28 we will specifically discuss images of children, and how historians can analyze these images and objects.

For this assignment, you need to choose a painting, sculpture, or historical material object (aka a primary source) from BEFORE the year 2000. The object or image can be from the National Museum of Play in Rochester, NY (see the database on: http://www.museumofplay.org/online-collections/; see Online Collections in the Access to Collections under Collections tab). It can also be from the Metropolitan Museum of Art in Manhattan (search the collection for children or related search terms, for instance: https://www.metmuseum.org/art/collection/search#!?q=children)

You then need to write a thesis, making an argument about how this object reflects certain values and conceptions of childhood in its particular historical context. It is not enough to just describe what the object is. You need to, through the objects appearance, or the paintings visual characteristics, make an argument about how a child used this object, or how a child was represented in this context, and how this use or representation tells historians something about a certain moment in the history of childhood.

Your paper must include: (1) The historical context of this object, and how Stearns, GHC, and BB readings from our class have defined childhood in that context. (The context is given to you by the label information on the website, where the objects Origin, date, and material are listed.) Explain this all to me as if I was a reader encountering this information for the first time. Dont assume that your reader understands anything about this historiographyexplain it to them, and make the connections between the object and its context explicit. Also note how this object might problematize, work against, or defy what our course authors have said about the relevant context or period. (2) The visual attributes of your object and image, and how that visual evidence proves aspects of your argument, especially in connection with the data you have collected about the historical context. (3) The methodological problems historians encounter with sources re: the history of childhood (e.g. sources for vs. sources by vs. sources about children), and how you have accounted for and avoided or acknowledged those problems in your analysis. (4) A thesis in the introduction of your paper.

Your paper must include a print out of the image/object and its label information. This means:
1. The origin, date, object ID, material of the object or image (if from the Museum of Play), and a photo/pdf of the image appended to your paper.
2. The artist, title, date, and accession number (looks like: 29.160.33) of the object or painting (if from the Metropolitan Museum of Art), and a photograph of the image or object appended to your paper.

YOU MAY NOT USE OUTSIDE RESEARCH, MUSEUM OF PLAY WEBSITE, MUSEUM PUBLICATIONS, or the INTERNET in constructing your analysis. Cite any information you take from the sources, class notes, or textbook in parenthetical citations like this : (Plumb BB, p. 4) (GHC, p. 134) (Stearns, p. 44) (Class, 10/14).

Helpful ways to read and think about the sources:
1. Objects: Discern the function(s) of each object. Function on the most basic level can be understood as what the object is designed to do. The function of diapers, for example, is to contain the excretions of a non-“potty trained” child. It is important, however, to go beyond the basic function to the more complex types of roles an object is supposed to fulfill. Who is supposed to use each item? Who is each item designed for? Are their “sub-groups” of users?
2. Paintings/Sculptures: Where is the child in the painting? Who is s/he with? What is s/he carrying? How is s/he similar to / different from the adults in the painting? What was the purpose of this image (memento, portrait, storytelling, etc.) and who was its audience?
3. Look at the style of the objects/paintings. These are aspects of the items that are not directly related to function (i.e., if these aspects were present, absent, or different the object would still function as intended but appear different). What types of ideas about children are reflected in these non-functional aspects of the items?
4. How do the images/objects problematize the category of child (adolescent? Toddler? Preschooler?) How do they give the child gender? How do they promote a normative way for a child to grow? How do they emphasize the preferences of the child vis a vis the preferences of the adult?

Use the order calculator below and get started! Contact our live support team for any assistance or inquiry.

[order_calculator]