Medical Paternalism

Be sure to read, Making Arguments III, in Canvas before doing this week’s forum!

This week’s forum requires a reply to the forum question and one reply to a classmate only.

As we saw in the lecture, sometimes doctors and scientists like Dr Henry Murray make mistakes. Most people condemn Kaczynski the adult terrorist but have some sympathy for the sixteen year old Kaczynski subjected to experiments that aimed to tear down the personalities of the subjects. As this example shows us, sometimes authorities, even medical authorities, simply get things wrong — really wrong.

I’d like you to continue to consider this issue as you listen to the documentary 81 Words that can be located at:

http://www.thisamericanlife.org/radio-archives/episode/204/81-words (Links to an external site.)

This documentary is weighed heavily to convince you that the early versions of DSM were based on culture and not science. Yet the changes came about because of heavy lobbying and dubious research.

THE QUESTION: The documentary ends with a question posed by an ethicist: Should science and medicine determine our morality for us? How should they interface?

Your assignment will be graded according to the grading rubric.

Starting at 100:

Composition:

Is the writing solid with clear attention to spelling and keeping grammatical error to a minimum?

Does the author practice proper citation practices with respect to the outside argument paraphrased for this week?

Argument (reply to forum question):

Is there a conclusion and reasons given for it?

Was an outside argument brought in as evidence according to the assignment instructions?

Is the argument well-developed and does it read as one continuous whole?

Confirmatory Argument:

Does paraphrase of argument contain at least three lines but no more than five?

Is the color of the confirmatory argument changed to green font?

Does the confirmatory argument act as part of the overall argument?

Conclusion:

Is conclusion specified in forum post by color change to blue?

Is conclusion limited to two sentences or less?

Does conclusion follow from evidence and reasons given?

Use the order calculator below and get started! Contact our live support team for any assistance or inquiry.

[order_calculator]