The bibliography project is a summary and assessment of the argument in three academic journal articles or book chapters from the scholarly literature on issues related to points Frede makes in A Free Will. You are to outline the argument the author makes, make a judgment about the plausibility of the argument, and give reasons for your judgment.
Here is an example.
“Free Will in Antiquity and in Kant,” Michael N. Forster. Metaphysics of Freedom? Kant’s Concept of Cosmological Freedom in Historical and Systematic Perspective, edited by Christian H. Krijnen. Critical Studies in German Idealism, 10-26, 23, 2018.
Forster sets out what he calls the “standard model” of free will (10). He says that the first step “took place when Socrates and Plato in the fifth and fourth centuries BC projected what had up till that time been the purely socio-political conceptions of freedom vs. slavery or unfreedom inwards into individual souls…” (11). He says that Socrates’ and Plato’s arguments for this are “vanishingly thin” (12) and that their real motivation consisted in their “shared feeling that contemporary socio-political lifein both its tyrannical and its radical democratic variantswas profoundly oppressive…” (12). “This,” he says, “caused them to seek (a) the illusory consolation of a sort of imaginary freedom that lay beyond the reach of socio-political oppression in the individual soul … and (b) the illusory satisfaction of their desire for revenge on their oppressors that was afforded by depicting them as merely inner slaves…” (12).
Forster does not provide much argument for his interpretation.
Forster seems to think the Apology shows that Socrates found life in Athens to be “profoundly oppressive.” It is true that Plato, in the Apology, makes the character Socrates call attention to the lack of interest in wisdom, but I do not think this is enough to show that Socrates found life in Athens “profoundly oppressive.” Further, we need an argument to show he “projected” a conception of freedom that applied to life in Athens “inwards into individual souls.”
For what Plato thought, Forster cites the Gorgias, Phaedo, Republic, and Seventh Letter. The Seventh Letter is weak evidence because scholars question whether Plato is the author. As for the Gorgias, Phaedo, Republic, they do suggest that Plato thought justice requires cities to be organized differently than they had been organized. They also suggest that Plato thought that the way some human beings live can be understood and described by saying that the person is a “slave to pleasure.” This, though, is too weak to establish Forster’s interpretation.
Another problem for Foster’s interpretation is that there is reason to think that the use of terms such as ‘slave’ to describe what happens in the mind in the case of some actions does not originate with Socrates and Plato. In the Protagoras, Socrates describes how “the many” think of knowledge as something that can be dragged around as a slave when someone is overcome by pleasure. The many are the people. They have the common, ordinary views about things.
Professor Recommendation:
For some of your bibliography entries, you might consider some chapters in Emotion and Peace of Mind, Richard Sorabji. (You can download this book from pdfdrive.) Sorabji is not always easy to understand, but he provides a contrast with Frede and includes some bibliography you might find useful.
Use the order calculator below and get started! Contact our live support team for any assistance or inquiry.
[order_calculator]
