On Crimes and Punishments and Other Writings by Cesare Beccaria

Book: On Crimes and Punishments and Other Writings by Cesare Beccaria
This assignment offers you the opportunity to demonstrate your ability to analyze Enlightenment thought in the context of a historiographical debate. Further, it demonstrates your ability to craft a strong, well-written, argumentative history paper.

Instructions
We have spent the past two weeks reading enlightenment discussions about crime and punishments. We have learned about the problematic nature of torture and physical punishments as well as the developing attempts to move away from them, which began in the sixteenth century but picked up steam in the eighteenth century. We have also learned about new standards for evidence and conviction which made torture less important as an investigatory tool.

With that knowledge, we can place Beccarias text and the responses to it in their historical context. Write a minimum five (5) page paper that analyzes the texts in their historical context and in the context of the history of crime and punishment. Some possible questions to consider include: Where do you see new elite understandings of crime, investigations, and proper punishment? Where do you see the same understandings, but simply changing (or not changing!) practices? Do you believe that Enlightenment thinkers like Beccaria and his respondents drove the shift, or were they just jumping on the bandwagon that was already leading to change, and what in the sources leads you to that conclusion? Who makes the better points, Beccaria or his opponents? These questions are guidelines, not demands, and you should feel free to contact me with a thesis statement or an outline as you wish.

Additional things to think about:

Picking one or two topics or themes that these sources discuss, how do the different authors argue against/for each other? On what do they base their arguments? Accepting that all four authors, three on one side and one on the other (mostly), are not always arguing from the same starting point, what are they really arguing about in the broader context of eighteenth-century Europe? To give an example: some are in favor of the death penalty, some are against it, some want it limited, and while that is interesting by itself, how and why they make their arguments elucidate broader discussions occurring in Enlightenment Europe. Those of you who have studied philosophy, economics, political science (the social contract), and so forth will find a number of connections here.

All papers (short and long) must be in 12-point Times New Roman font, double-spaced, with one inch margins. Citations must be complete in Turabian format as footnotes. I have posted a series of writing tips and strategies on the course website that I encourage you to read as it comes from years of experience with undergraduates, colleagues, and my own writing. It also includes a list of simple errors that, because they are easy fixes (unlike, say, analysis, which is not easy), will result in automatic deductions to your papers grade. You will also find a peer-review sheet if you wish to practice peer-review with a classmate. These peer-review sheets are also good checklists for self-review.

Use the order calculator below and get started! Contact our live support team for any assistance or inquiry.

[order_calculator]