Surrealism and SVU (Comparison and Close Reading)

Purpose:
For the first part of class, I have been encouraging you to observe, to pay attention to even the smallest of detailswhether it be the use of a word, repetition of a phrase, the thickness of a panel gutter, the number of lines in a stanza, or the prevalence of one colorbecause these small details contribute to the meaning of the whole, and are often subtly significant. Primarily, I have been asking you to look closely at word choice/image design and the connotations those choices evoke subconsciously, because it is the word choice (or the perspective of the image) that shapes the message and larger themes of a text.

Now that you have analysis conquered, it is time to put those skills towards making a focused claima point that your analysis reveals. We are going to begin with what is considered perhaps a simple type of argument: a comparison claim. As I mentioned earlier, comparison arguments have several risks: they can be boring, fall into simple description, get sucked into plot summaryin other words they can seem pointless. The goal here is to examine something to explain why the comparison mattersnot just to point out that there is a relationship.

Context:
Law and Order SVU has been on the air for over 20 years, entertaining people with stories of rape and sexual violence. Especially Heinous is offering a critique of not only the show, it seems, but of the culture that loves the show so much. Rather than outright critique the show through an argumentative essay, Machado uses the device of surrealism to offer an opportunity for insight, to jolt you to see reality more clearly.

Directions:
Generate and support a claim about the meaning or point of the surrealism used in Especially Heinous. You are essentially asking and answering the question, What is Machado trying to show or reveal to us about SVU by using surrealism? You will defend a claim through close analysis of both Law and Order SVU and Especially Heinous. Unlike the previous writing we have done in class, you will need to use essay structure: this means having a thesis, introduction, paragraphing, clear grammar, MLA format, etc.

It is important that you focus on one element. Do not try to cover the entire story. Focus.

Options:
Lets take as the premise that Machados goal is to reveal something to us about reality that we ignore or for some reason just cannot see. She is using the story to get us to not only see the reality more clearly but also to reveal what blinds us to understanding this reality. Almost as if she is saying reality keeps us from seeing reality.

What version of police work and the handling of rape does the show itself create? (There are more options here, but am pressed for time)
How do words and their meanings shape reality? This might include names, but in particular the episode titles.

Remember these are just starting pointsthese are not prescriptions or requirements. I am just trying to get you started.

Your thesis:
You will need a thesis for this paper, and it will not be in this paper I will analyze the story Especially Heinous for its use of surrealism. Nor will it be Surrealism shows us many things about our world. Neither of these present a position you need to defendnor are they compelling.

Your thesis needs to be the point or the idea you discover through your analysis. What should we learn by juxtaposing Especially Heinous with Law and Order SVU? I am being deliberately vague here because these statements will differ for all of you. Just keep in mind that your thesis is not a description of what you are doing in the paper; it is what you revealed through doing it.

A Possible Crutch for those of you who are desperate (again this is not a requirement):

Let me be honest here, I really dont like to offer formatting guidelines because I think they are prescriptive and often stunt your ideasit is like writing with a crutch, and while you may like the support, sometimes the crutch wont let you run very fast or far. But I know that some of you may need it, at least to get started. So here is a possible plan:

Lead paragraph will summarize Especially Heinous or will describe Law and Order SVU
The first section will set-up and explain the surrealist element. You may have to trace it through the storychart its evolution (?)
The second section will add to that analysis by discussing the reality the surrealist element is highlighting
The third section will then connect this back to SVU and the problems Machado is asking us to see.
The conclusion will explain why this matters

What I am looking for:
Close analysis: paying attention to small details.
Integrating evidence smoothly into your writing (effective quoting)
Making connections between evidence from the texts and your interpretations
A thesis that declares your point and focuses the argument
Paragraphing (i.e. topic sentences, coherence, concluding sentences)

Use the order calculator below and get started! Contact our live support team for any assistance or inquiry.

[order_calculator]